By some estimates, the nonprofit sector accounts for some 5.3–5.6% of US gross domestic product. Not only that, but the employment provided by US nonprofits may account for up to 8.6% of nonfarm payroll. But beyond the financial statistics, there is no question that our society would be so much poorer in every way without the good work of charitable organizations and the private foundations and family philanthropic efforts that sustain them. And for many families with significant means, giving back to the local community and even to society at large is a core value and a significant part of their identity.

But for individuals and families who are considering such efforts, some important decisions need to come first. Creating a meaningful philanthropic estate planning legacy for multigenerational impact requires integrating philanthropic wealth planning with overall financial planning. It also requires including tax-efficient giving strategies in order to preserve and prolong the impact of wealth intended to sustainably support charitable efforts for the long haul.

Of course, persons who are dedicated to creating a philanthropic legacy aren’t solely concerned with tax efficiency. They also want to use their resources in a way that reflects their values without compromising the family’s financial future. A well-constructed philanthropic estate plan can empower legacy giving without compromising the wealth-building engine that sustains it.

How do I leave a charitable legacy that reflects my values?

For affluent families desiring to create and sustain a philanthropic legacy, the first place to start is by answering some basic questions about purpose, interest, and values. In a previous article, we recommended considering a few foundational factors:

  • Need.  Many founders of philanthropic organizations will spend months or more performing a detailed needs analysis, including a survey of other organizations that might have similar missions and objectives.
  • Purpose.  A clear mission statement will help crystallize goals and methods, including granting guidelines and target sectors.
  • Business plan.  Just like a for-profit enterprise, charitable organizations need detailed operating plans and procedures in order to function efficiently.
  • Governance.  Depending on the form your philanthropic efforts take, you should recruit the most qualified people you can find—preferably those who share a passion for your desired objectives—to serve as advisors or, in the case of a family foundation, on your board of directors.

 

Your consideration of these factors should be driven by your vision for the legacy you want to create and your family’s particular interests. What issues, organizations, or causes are you passionate about? What do you see as the most critical needs that you want to help address? Are there other organizations who are already doing work in the area of your interest? If not, should you consider creating an organization to address the needs you see?

Once you have the answers to foundational questions like these, you’ll want to create documents that spell out your intentions, goals, and even your dreams for the effort. In some cases, this may be as simple as a charitable or philanthropic vision statement to guide current and future efforts. Or it may involve creating a formal structure such as a family foundation, including a charter, bylaws, and a detailed corporate structure.

How do I include philanthropy in my estate plan?

For many affluent families, the philanthropic mission is a core component of estate planning. Establishing a philanthropic estate planning legacy means looking beyond a single donation and thinking holistically and for the long term, perhaps decades into the future. How does giving fit alongside your income, investments, taxes, and long-term goals? How do those plans fit alongside your intentions to provide for future generations of your family? When philanthropy is integrated in this way, it can support the causes you care about while also reducing tax friction. By strategically directing assets toward charity, large estates may be able to reduce the size of the taxable estate—saving heirs the expense of excess taxation when the estate is transferred to them—while also providing for the needs of both their favored charitable causes and current family members who depend on the estate for maintaining their chosen lifestyle.

Wealthy families structure long-term philanthropic giving in various ways, depending on their resources, the needs of the family, and the level of involvement they want to have in the ongoing philanthropic effort. These structures can be relatively simple, such as the use of a donor-advised fund (DAF) to receive gifted assets and distribute them to qualified charities, or more complex, such as the establishment of a family foundation with specific governance, legal, and tax attributes that dictate its charitable activities.

What is a donor-advised fund versus a family foundation?

As we explained in a previous article, donor-advised funds (DAFs) are organizations designed to receive gifts of assets in various forms (not restricted to cash), liquidate them as needed, and distribute the proceeds to charities as advised by the donor. When the assets are deposited with the fund, donors receive an immediate charitable deduction equivalent to the fair market value of the asset at the time of donation. DAFs offer a convenient way for the family organization to pool assets from a number of sources and distribute to charities matching the family’s principal philanthropic interests. Using a DAF can be a simple, low-cost way to receive and direct charitable gifts over as many years as needed, and donors can also remain anonymous, if they wish. Gifts to a DAF can even be stipulated in a trust (more on this below).

A family foundation, on the other hand, involves more preparation, design, and ongoing administration. Because a foundation exists as a separate legal entity, creating one requires careful thought and coordination with qualified legal counsel, tax experts, and professional financial advisors. Funding for a family foundation typically comes from a single individual, a family, or a family-owned business. Advantages of private family foundations include their ability, as a stand-alone entity, to carry on the family legacy in perpetuity. Foundations also typically have their own employees and directors, which often include family members. Because of the cost associated with establishing a family foundation, significantly more assets are typically needed to make this a practical solution. There are also ongoing filing and reporting obligations for family foundations, since they are required to distribute a minimum amount of assets each year, along with meeting other requirements, to maintain their nonprofit status.

What are charitable trusts and how do they work?

A charitable remainder trust (CRT) is an irrevocable (cannot be altered or retracted) giving vehicle funded with a gift. The trust may be structured so that a beneficiary (such as a spouse) receives payments from the trust for a term of years or life and a qualified charity receives the assets remaining in the trust at the end of the term (as mentioned above, the remaining assets may also be directed to a donor-advised fund). The donor may claim a charitable deduction in the year the trust is funded, and the deduction amount is typically based on the present fair market value of the assets that will eventually go to the named charity. Setting up a trust requires the assistance of a qualified legal representative.

For persons who intend to provide a charitable benefit immediately rather than after the expiration of a term or the passing of a beneficiary, a charitable lead trust (CLT) can be a useful tool. Like a CRT, a CLT is irrevocable, but in contrast, the CLT provides an immediate income stream to a selected charity for a specified term. Upon the end of the term, remaining assets in the trust are distributed to a beneficiary chosen by the grantor (the person or entity that created the trust). CLTs, then, can be a useful way to direct gifts to charity now, while also providing for the financial support of a beneficiary in the future.

At Optima Asset Management, we understand that our clients’ charitable and philanthropic interests are usually best served when carefully integrated with their overall wealth management strategy. We can work with you to design a plan that both honors and supports your philanthropic legacy and also supports the financial security of future generations. Let us help you find solutions that are right for you.